I am bad at many, many things. I'm horrible at foreign languages. I'm pretty lousy at completing projects in a timely manner. I'm no good at getting bread to rise. I construct flimsy arguments that are easily poked through with holes. I can't seem to figure out the breathing in swimming. I almost never listen to phone messages (perhaps a sin rather than a failure). I'm late returning emails. The list could go on endlessly.
But I'm usually pretty good at one thing: reading my students. I know when they're confused. I can sense when they're engaged. I see it when they're on the verge of discovery. I know when to slow down and try another avenue. But this semester, well, not so much. My students, 17 young and diverse women, are completely and totally inscrutable to me. Don't get me wrong, there are moments that seem electric and I know everything is working--like during a particularly exciting conversation about Margaret Fuller's obsession with the Romans--but there are far more moments when I haven't a clue. They stonewall me every third class, and when two of them giggle on the far side of the table, I fear that they're laughing at just how stupid my question really was. A few are totally silent and several talk voluminously, without seeming to pause for breaths.
When I'm really, truly honest with myself I know that they've actually done nothing to suggest that they don't like the class. When my paranoia mounted to such a degree that I needed something to give (I used guilt as my pedagogical tool of choice), they blurted something out about loving me. But I didn't believe them, at least not for more than an hour. I can't seem to figure all this out. Even when I doubt everything about myself, when I feel nothing but dread at my chosen path, teaching has always been the thing that I could do really well. It was a place of affirmation. But something seems amiss; something has shifted and not in a good way.
I think it's about being at this particular college. It's not unlike my own alma mater, a place where I learned to value teaching genius. And I remember well what I -- and my pals -- revered: the wit, the erudition, the brilliance of a mind in front of a class. I didn't value a decentered classroom. I didn't long for student discussion. I wanted to be wowed by a brain on fire. And I wasn't often disappointed. I carry the weight of these expectations into my current teaching, even as I know how pedagogically foolish, how utterly unproductive to real learning, these techniques often are. But still.
I'm rarely a brain on fire. Mostly, I'm just a slightly anxious and often blunted teacher trying to motivated engaged discussion. Even when it happens, when everyone talks and everyone actually seems to listen, I don't leave feeling fantastic. I leave wishing I had proclaimed the truths of the universe.